One of the main arguments in the
reading for today by Samantha Kwan concerns health issues caused by obesity.
The Center for Consumer Freedom along with the Fat Acceptance Activists at the
National Association to Fat Acceptance argue that obesity does not have adverse
health effects and one can be obese while still leading a healthy lifestyle.
While other behaviors such as smoking and drug use do cause one to have health
issues, obesity is another way for people to fall into a lifestyle that can
lead to serious illness. According to the reading there is a direct link from
obesity to health concerns such as type 2 diabetes, hypertension, heart disease
and some forms of cancer. I am in agreement with the Center for Disease Control
and the Medical Frame described by Kwan. I personally do not think obesity
should be looked at as lightly as the CCF and the FAFAA take it to be. Although
I do no think society should look at people with obesity differently than an
average sized human being, I do think that obese people should be aware of the
risks of being overweight in order to help them live a long healthy life.
Samantha Kwan talks about the FAFAA
and the Social Justice frame in the reading as well. This frame focuses on
obese individuals who are confident in their bodies, but is this good for their
health? Of course it is always a great thing to be confident in yourself and
who you are as a person, in fact it is one of the most important things in
life. However, in order to enjoy this confidence throughout your whole life you
must be alive and well. Most obese individuals are not in this category
though. It is mostly due to society and the "average" opinion of bodies. Appearances
are valued very high around the world today, and having a “skinny” or “fit”
body is usually valued higher than an obese body. Although I do not agree that
society should look down upon people who are bigger than others it is still
happening everywhere. However, this epidemic causes people to make a change when
they see fit.
When I was in High school I used to
watch the television series The Biggest
Loser every Tuesday night with my family, we were really into reality
shows... It amazed me to see the transformation throughout one season. Not only
do the individuals on the show look healthier and happier, but they feel way
better about themselves and gain an immense amount of confidence when they lose
weight. One of my favorite episodes that they do each season is where the
contestants sit down with their trainers and look back on their journey. They
each talk about how they became obese and why they want to lose the weight, then
a video is played of their journey on the show thus far. This episode really
sticks out to me because of the how contestants emotionally respond. You can
see from their reactions to their video that they are so proud of what they
accomplished and strive to get leaner and healthier during the rest of their
life.
In the video above there was a man on the show
whose wife died and he made a promise to her to be around to take care of their
daughters, in order to do this he felt that he needed to lose weight because of
the adverse health effects caused by obesity. Additionally, there is a female
swimmer who had gained a bunch of weight after ending her career and she had
lost all of her self-confidence and even “part of her identity” in her words.
These are two examples of obese people who made a change in order to be
healthier and feel better about themselves. They are the people who are
examples of how obesity can alter the lives of people and how when they finally
realize it they can make a change and lead a better life, emotionally and
physically.
I believe that obesity is directly
linked to very serious health issues and although people in society need to
treat people dealing with obesity equally, these health concerns need to be
made aware of so people who are obese can make a change and possibly save their
own lives.
While you described the experiences of the two contestants on the show, it made me realize how closely related all three frames are. While each has its own particular focus, features of the individual frames can be see in one another. While I agree that the medical frame is quite important in deterring the rate and prevalence of obesity, I also feel that the social justice frame is equally as important. Preventing major health problems should be a concern, but also feeling comfortable in your own skin should serve as a source of empowerment. This is slightly where choice plays a role. If there is no desire or incentive, then why make a life altering choice? Although, obesity should be an issue that is adequately addressed regardless of any frame used.
ReplyDeleteThe article was definitely interesting and probably the most interesting and fun we've read so far. There were two things that arose though when reading the article and viewing the websites: first, society places emphasis on being beautiful which is associated with the in-shape more toned body and second, the social justice view is flawed in that it tells individuals who are larger to love themselves even though their health is in peril…they're openly endorsing a food system that is corrupt with dangerous growing habits, high amounts of sugar and sodium, etc. If they (SJ POV) truly want to help larger people, their message should center around making healthier eating habits and that if they want to love themselves and those around the m, they should care about their health. I couldn't help but notice that all three frames also disregard a strong,centralized public push to reduce obesity in the US, but promote individualism which assumes a self-regulation market and it blatantly promotes a do-nothing policy regarding public policy and health.
ReplyDeleteI just read an article about the Biggest Loser not too long ago, it was about how Ryan Benson gained all of his weight back and is now 300 pounds.http://www.today.com/id/40423712/ns/today-today_entertainment/t/biggest-loser-where-are-they-now/#.U5XCD_ldXT8.
ReplyDeleteI started doing some more research into other contestants and very few have actually kept the weight off for long periods of time. I think one of the problems with how the health industry runs is that when you're morbidly obese the goal is seen as getting thin as quick as possible but then you are left with excess skin, that needs surgery to be removed, and the new diet and exercise routine are seen as done instead of a permanent lifestyle choice. I read a scientific study that said "Only about five per cent of people who try to lose weight ultimately succeed in keeping the weight off". I think the issue at hand is more than a quick fix or an obese problem it is a health problem that affects people of all body frames and sizes, how the majority of people use and fuel their bodies in modern times can make anyone at any shape unhealthy and changing behavior quickly and drastically is unrealistic for long time success.
I think you bring up several good points. I agree with you belief in the idea that people that are obese need to be treated equally, but will that really happen. In the article it stated that obese individuals historically were seen as healthy or wealthy. Skinny individuals historically were looked at as sick or poor because they couldn't afford to eat as much. In our generation its quite the opposite. Those who our obese are looked at as poor, because they can’t afford to pay for "good" and healthy foods, along with finding the time to exercise. However, "skinny" or fit individuals are praised for taking care of their bodies. Being in shape is "beautiful" in our society .Our society has unrealistic expectations. I don’t think enough emphasis is placed on a person’s financial standing. Our society judges purely on appearance.
ReplyDeleteA person's fatness is always under scrutiny when health is involved. Just because a person is fat does not mean that they cannot be healthy and maintain good health while being fat. The health focus that criminalizes fat people into changing their bodies to adhere to the social ideal (white, fit/skinny, and wealthy) is a lot more ingrained in medical movements as well. Just as Jihad said, those people that are fat are associated with being poor and unable to afford the foods that lead to "a long healthy life" in reality being properly nourished with the optimal amount of vitamins and engaging in exercise does not make someone fit or skinny. I believe that some bodies are fat and that is not a consequence of morality or social failure or a lack of dieting. Many cultures view fat as abhorrent and wrong which does in fact influence how people perceive fat folks.
ReplyDeleteThis reading really hit home for me. My Dad had a heart attack about 8 years ago and since then he has gained a lot of weight around his middle. He can't do anything about it because he can't even walk very far without getting short of breath. My mother always comments about his belly and how he should do something about it, even though she knows that he can't. My grandfather always asks if he is pregnant and proceeds to laugh. It must make my Dad feel terrible that all these people expect him to lose all this weight while knowing that he can't, but they still make comments based on how they think he should look. That psychological stress is probably doing more to hurt his already fragile health than it is to motivate him to lose weight, because he can't. If someone can lose weight it is better to try to introduce gradual health practices than to try to get them to lose weight all at once or pounce on them for being fat. That can be extremely detrimental to the person's psychological well being and the weight most likely won't stay off even if they do start to lose weight.
ReplyDelete