Tuesday, May 20, 2014

Sublimation of Objectification is My Demonstration

When you think of the objectification of a sex, you typically think of female...right? I hadn't realized the pressures that men have on them to have a body that portrays their "level of masculinity". In the reading, "Men's Bodies: Listening to the Voices of Young Gay Men" the phenomena regarding how societies image of the ideal male body is one that portrays his masculinity. Masculinity, as it is defined in this reading, is thought of as being contingent upon a man's physical strength. The main issue discussed in this reading is where gay men fall in this masculine/feminine society.
Contrary to popular belief, Gay men consider themselves to be masculine in our categorizing-obsessed society. Although they do feel that one's masculinity should not be either present or not, but rather a scale or spectrum. Society portrays a gay man as a weak, feminine, flamboyant person.
 While there are many gay men who fit this image, there are those who still strive for the body of a masculine man - broad shoulders, big muscles, and rough-looking - for the purposes of "picking-up" other men. The way advertisements/tv shows/movies and other media outlets portray what a straight man and gay man should look like puts a lot of pressure on the gay man to either look womanly so he can be "picked-up" or look manly so he can do the "picking-up". These pressures do result in eating disorders.
The issue of male objectification is so easily overlooked because it isn't as prominent in our society as that of women. This is because those who most strongly suffer from the effects of male objectification are gay men, a small but marginalized group of men in our society. I have provided a music video by Jennifer Lopez that was created for the sole purpose of objectifying men. The male physique is the foundation this video was built on. In the beginning of the video J-Lo says men are never objectified and it's their turn to be sexualized. Which is a very ignorant assumption. Her video supports the idea that there is a ideal male body that is seen as the "most attractive" which in turn can result in gay men, who are more likely to have an eating disorder due to the fact that men within gay culture place an emphasis on physical attractiveness and are "like women...more likely to be dissatisfied with their bodies."



After many interviews with gay men, Drummond learned that many gay men find themselves conforming to the image of what a man is supposed to look like and the behavior that he is supposed to take part in when they are in the view of the general public. However, when among members of the gay society they will act and dress in a more outgoing and extroverted way. They feel they have to hide their homosexuality as to avoid being discriminated against. This is a perfect example of the idea that people don't have a set identity, and that their behaviors and the way they present themselves is contingent upon the social structure they are in and the people they are with. It is important to remember the all men are subject to scrutiny regarding their body image, however those more susceptible to the pressures society places on them are those who's "identity is...linked to the image that one portrays." Research has shown that these men are most commonly young gay men. This situation may seem negative but there is a light at the end of this microscope. They have become more aware of their surroundings and the way people perceive them. Marginalized groups are more likely to view the world through a sociological lens.


5 comments:

  1. I really enjoyed your perspective on the issue of masculinity and eating disorders among gay men. There certainly is a stereotype for the gay man perpetuated by TV shows and movies: the overly flamboyant best friend to the strong female lead, her shopping partner, but never her protector. The reality is is that gay men don't fit into one category in the same way that straight men don't, or gay women, or straight women. I think that gay men who strive for chiseled bodies and prominent muscles are doing so more than just to "pick up." Given, there is a strong presence of this, but just like with straight men there are some who are simply health conscious and are maintaing their physique for themselves just as much as for other men. Drummond also interviewed gay men who purposely went out of their ways to be overly flamboyant in an effort to push people out of their comfort zones and make them uncomfortable. In these cases these men might have been more masculine, but played into the gay stereotype in an effort to make a point. I found this to be very interesting! But it made me think, don't we all, to some extent, play into stereotypes about us? I know I've been guilty on more than one occasion of Instagramming an overly filtered picture of my Starbucks cup with the caption #whitegirlproblems. It just goes to show that people are people, regardless of orientation and gender, and that at the end of the day we all have similar motivations and impulses.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Very good blog, I enjoyed how you gave multiple examples of what a ideal masculine male is suppose to look like. The Jennifer Lopez video in particular was a great demonstration of how media sources usually focus on ideal bodies. She defintiely went over-the-top with the whole video, but one thing that I found interesting that many probably overlooked was how they portrayed the male in the beginning of the video. The male in the introduction was made to portray a gay male who's career was somewhat in a feminine realm (set designer). This ventures into a deeper sociological problem. Specifically, that gay males are believed to excel in feminine careers, such as being hair dressers, designers, etc. In addition, this man was wearing a very generic masculine outfit, which directly relates to what Drummond described regarding gays attempting to "blend in" when in public. Thus, this video had several different examples of Drummond's findings with regards to masculine male bodies and gay individuals.

    ReplyDelete
  3. There were multiple points that I agree with you on your analysis of the readings. The idealization of male or female bodies is definitely a source of body shaming and self injury (via eating disorders as you mentioned above) that goes on in multiple groups, specifically gay men as you stated. With the use of online dating sites and accounts from gay men who use those sites, there are instances where these men will promptly state the features they find most attractive. Without surprise the features you mentioned, masculinity and muscles along with certain rugged features were the most looked for in other candidates. This brings in the idealization of only certain body types and the number of people who undergo preparations to achieve that body.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The Jennifer Lopez video is a great example of how this objectification of bodies and the constant portrayal of the "ideal" body is conveyed through the media and other outlets. When public figures like celebrities perpetuate these norms and ideals it has the power to affect and influence a large, young audience. I think this may be an area to address the continuing problem of trying to obtain the ideal body image. If the message that gets sent to the public changes in a large enough manner, maybe the notion of what the perfect body is can change and that whatever body you have is the "ideal" body. Also, in regards to the Messner article, changing the way sports are played (though an arduous task) may also help reshape body image. Athletes without large muscles and violent behavior or more coverage of women's sports may help young people believe that they don't have to change who or what they are in order to conform to the societal norm.

    ReplyDelete
  5. My opinion is masculinity in media is portrayed as a strongly built man. Homosexual men do have to hide their identities because they aren't welcomed in society. I'm not sure about how homosexual men create their appearance to look attractive to other men but it does seem like a reasonable suggestion. I agree with what the reading stated about the women bodies and how they body shaming for them. Females go through a lot because they always want to shape their image as how it is portrayed in the media

    ReplyDelete